Sundance Film Festival last year, one documentary garnered particular praise and
attention: the Oscar-nominated How to
Survive a Plague. And let's hope that on the 24th of February, it's David
France and Howard Gertler - along with a host of others: the cast who "play"
themselves - who get on the stage at the Dolby Theatre to accept those
universally-recognized golden statuettes.
study the splendid shenanigans of Sundance any more; no longer an earnest young
cinephile. So it was a surprise to come across news and reviews of another "break-out"
(why use a different adjective, journalists, when the Dictionary of Clichés is always handy?)
documentary about HIV/AIDS at this year's festival: Dylan Mohan Gray's
directorial debut, Fire in the Blood.
film's Facebook (and IMDb) page:
"An intricate tale of 'medicine,
monopoly and malice,' Fire in the Blood
tells the story of how Western pharmaceutical companies and governments blocked
access to low-cost AIDS drugs for the countries of the global south in the
years after 1996 -- causing ten million or more unnecessary deaths -- and the
improbable group of people who decided to fight back.
"Shot on four
continents and including contributions from global figures such as Bill
Clinton, Desmond Tutu and Joseph Stiglitz, Fire
in the Blood is the never-before-told true story of the remarkable
coalition which came together to stop 'the crime of the century' and save
millions of lives in the process."
indifference: vastnesses of suffering, a fragile half-century of progress
shattered in whole countries, a trail of death that requires seven zeroes after
the number 1 to be even approximately mapped, enumerated - that's "the crime of
the century" being chronicled here. Fiery stuff indeed.
seen the film, so I can't comment on its cinematic power, its technical
prowess, its structure, and so on. Those who have seen the documentary,
however, give it very high marks. (A sampling of reviews and quotes, below.)
And many have commented that Fire in the
Blood is a "global sequel" to How to
Survive a Plague.
* * *
the movie's Facebook page (www.facebook.com/fireintheblood)
for news of screenings, more assessments, comments and conversations, and
videos (interviews, the trailer). But here are a few other sites you might want
to visit; I've extracted a few passages from them, to provide a sample of what
it is that this documentary documents.
"And the one film that
I'd put to the top of your must-see list is Fire in the Blood. This
World category entry, directed by Dylan Mohan Gray, who's based in Mumbai, is
about how Western pharmaceutical companies block access to cheaper medicines in
developing nations, in turn denying people access to AIDS-combatting drugs.
Gray speaks to survivors, doctors, and activists. He lays it all out...
"This may be a must-see
film but don't think of it as spinach. (Or, if it is, it's as if it were
prepared by Alain Ducasse.) Gray crosses the planet and manages to set up a lot
of breath-taking wide shots of faraway places that make this a beautiful film
to watch. And he talks to people who give great interviews, including Bill
Clinton and several mavericks who've led the fight against the pharmaceutical
"Really, Fire in the
Blood should be considered a companion film to David France's
much-championed Oscar-nominated film, How to Survive a Plague, about the
AIDS activist movement of the 1980s and 1990s. That was history. But the plague
continues in the rest of the world." (Tom Roston)
"While How to Survive a Plague and We Were Here have commendably essayed
the U.S. end of the AIDS crisis, the devastation the disease has wrought in the
developing world is a topic that has long merited a documentary of equivalent
substance. Enter Fire in the Blood, a
basically constructed but rivetingly researched examination of the global fight
for affordable antiretroviral therapy against Western pharmaceutical companies,
whose restrictive patent laws amount to a death sentence for millions of Third
World HIV/AIDS patients. Impassioned, persuasive film won't have trouble
spreading its essential message across the fest circuit and beyond."
"[A]fter a mid-2000s
breakthrough that led to a 1,000% increase in African patients receiving
treatment by 2012, the door looks ominously likely to close again at the behest
of the World Trade Organization." (Guy Lodge)
"Picking up more or
less where [HTSAP] left off, Fire
in the Blood is in a sense a global sequel, showing how AIDS activist
groups [a provocative claim about activists in the affluent "global north" -
JV] and government bodies turned their backs on the plight of Africa, a
continent that by 2000 had more than two-thirds of the world's cases of HIV
"Given the prohibitive
pricing of branded drugs and the trade restrictions that kept cheaper generic
alternatives out of reach, Africa had minimal access to lifesaving medications
for years after they became available. According to one statistic cited by George W. Bush in his 2003 State of
the Union address, out of 30 million Africans with HIV, only 50,000 were
"The explanation for
how that genocide of indifference was allowed to continue for so long and now
risks a recurrence after some years of reprieve is simple. It boils down to
blatant manipulation by the pharmaceutical giants. The most profitable industry
on the planet strictly interprets the word 'patent' to mean 'monopoly.'
"Just as France's film
identified heroes within the movement, so too does Gray focus on a handful of
individuals who made a difference. Among them are James P. Love, an American intellectual property activist; Dr. Peter Mugyenyi, head of the
largest HIV treatment and research center in Uganda; Zackie Achmat, a South African AIDS activist; and Yusuf Hamied, the Indian scientist
behind the socially conscious pharmaceutical manufacturer Cipla."
narrative outlines the plan spearheaded by Hamied to slash the cost of generic
antiretrovirals for poor countries, and provide their governments with the know-how
and technology to manufacture their own drugs. When that offer found no takers
at the European Commission in Brussels, Hamied and his colleagues then returned
with a second proposal that eliminated all overheads, charging only for the
ingredients. That step made sense purely on a humanitarian level, not
an economic one.
"The wall of willful
ignorance put up against this strategy by the World Health Organization, UNAIDS
and by U.S. and European governments in the stranglehold of the pharmaceutical
lobby is expertly outlined. But mounting political and public pressure
ultimately broke the blockade.
"The film is extremely
moving as it illustrates the overwhelmingly positive impact of affordable ARVs
in African countries. But that uplifting chapter ends abruptly. While Big
Pharma conceded the battle, the industry won the war by enlisting the World
Trade Organization as its global bully to protect future profits." (David Rooney)
* * *
the battles and the wars continue, on many fronts. And stories, an infinitude, continue to be
told. And, sometimes, movies get made that chronicle the victories and defeats,
movies that look into abysses and stare, as well, at the empyrean; movies which become part of the chronicle
itself. Let's hope many of us get to see this one.