Subscribe to:
POZ magazine
Join POZ: Facebook MySpace Twitter Pinterest
Tumblr Google+ Flickr Instagram
POZ Personals
Sign In / Join

"Why did you come out?" "Because."


"What are days for?" is the irritatingly simple question. "Days are where we live" is the deliberately pat and deceptively flat answer (or at least one answer, from a Philip Larkin poem). But days are also there, thank goodness, for the sake of having names given to them. Days are where we commemorate and celebrate someone or something; days are what we use to mark a tragedy or indulge in some purposeful frivolity. I happen to like, in particular, September 24: that is National Punctuation Day as well as Hug a Vegetarian Day. But there are days dedicated, it would seem, to just about everything -- from popcorn (January 19) to mental health (St. Dymphna's Feast Day, May 15) to Joyce/Ulysses (Bloomsday, June 16) to the scourge of HIV (World AIDS Day, December 1). And this Monday, as many of you know, was, among other things, National Coming Out Day. Every October 11, for the past 18 years, I've worn a pink triangle somewhere on my body. Intensely self-conscious, in my early twenties, of that giant and laser-bright (or so it seemed) pink beacon, I've actually had to make an effort, in recent years, to remember the occasion and re-affirm its importance. The more things change, the more they remain the same? So goes the old (French-originating) aphorism. But it's been irritating me for a while, so I'm going to thumb my nose at it and say: Nah.

October 11 had a different valence for me this year: less than two months ago (55 days ago but who's counting?) I came out "officially" -- to the world at large and on the World Wide Web -- as being HIV-positive. Since I was not a contestant on Project Runway (rooting for you, Mondo!) I used a different technological medium: I said what I needed through a status update on Facebook: "I told an old friend I have HIV. She cried. Well, I'm coming out, I want the world to know (are those lyrics, eh?). Have been positive for five years exactly. Details upon request of course." That was that. As comments were made, and private messages and e-mails came in, I felt obliged to offer an explanation, in a comment of my own, for the manner if not the matter of my coming out: "Apologies for the somewhat sudden and dramatic 'announcement.' In an ideal world I would have liked to talk to each person in person; but several dozen plane trips or even a few hundred phone calls seemed unrealistic." Well: that's the disadvantage of having peripatetic friends and being somewhat nomadic yourself: you don't have the luxury of individual or "personalized" coming-out talks, and you miss out on the wonderful catharsis of actual rather than virtual hugs (and, occasionally, tears). True that, sadly, mos def.


I was out, in a limited way of course, about my status, before this general coming out. In the first year after seroconverting I told a dozen people; in the next four years probably another 30. Maybe 40 even, I didn't keep track. So it's never been an entirely solitary trudge; my poz closet has never been a completely sealed-off space; and in rough times I've had friends I could count on. In fact, the real annoyance, as the five-year "anniversary" approached, was not being totally out. HIV has become part of the background hum of my life. By that I certainly don't mean to say I've fully domesticated "my pet virus" (to borrow Shawn Decker's wonderful phrase) or that I take my health for granted or that I go about spouting that mindless "What's-the-big-fucking-deal-you-whiners?" crap. But I have grappled with some demons, and I've either killed them or negotiated some (shaky? durable?) peace treaties. Having made my peace, I needed to say my piece as it were: being closeted doesn't agree with me. I know it sounds like a weak explanation, but it's a matter of temperament. "That is his temperament," writes J.M. Coetzee, of the protagonist in the resolutely unconsoling novel Disgrace. "His temperament is not going, he is too old for that. His temperament is fixed, set. The skull followed by the temperament: the two hardest parts of the body."


That's a casual, and decent enough, explanation of my coming out. But it wouldn't have satisfied Aristotle. (Aside: I hated reading him in college, as the driest of the dry; and I conveniently blame him, along with Anglo-Saxon poetry, for my youthful smoking habit. So it was a pleasant recent surprise to hear him described, in the words of a gossipy ancient biographer, as having "a lisping voice," and that "he used to indulge in very conspicuous dress, and rings, and used to dress his hair carefully." Sounds like Oscar Wilde in Oscar de la Renta at the Oscars.) Aristotle believed that, behind the existence of an object or the performance of an action, there were four causes -- material, formal, efficient, and final -- and that unless you were able to articulate, in each case, what the four causes were, your explanation or causal answer was incomplete and inadequate. This is difficult territory to cover in brief, but I'm going to give it a shot. Here goes...


"Why did you come out?" The efficient cause (the contemporary sense of cause, as in "X caused Y to happen") or "trigger" was the phone conversation with my friend; it pushed me to do something, i.e. post my status as a status update on Facebook. But what did this trigger act upon? That's the material cause -- me, my body, my brain, the neural connections at that time in my brain. That's still not enough, for this matter is not only the object of change but also its subject -- in Aristotle's terms, the formal cause. The trigger event acted upon some matter, and that action resulted in that matter achieving a different form or shape -- a transition from "merely" being matter to matter having "coming-out shape," or a rewired brain-state (let's say for the moment) that allows my being out as a poz man. Finally, the final (and most important) cause: the purpose or ultimate goals of my coming out. There is certainly a selfish purpose at work here, namely the desire to minimize the time and effort involved in telling each friend, each colleague, each (potential) partner the same thing ("Guess what? I have a certain pet virus which I acquired five years ago") over and over and over again. But there is also a hopeful goal: the desire to rob the closet, in however small a way, of its power to shame and stigmatize.


Put these four causes together -- the trigger (phone conversation) acting upon matter (my grey matter pre-coming out) that changes form (grey matter altered) for a set of goals (selfish as well as hopeful) -- and you have a comprehensive answer to the question, "Why did you come out?" Let's hope Aristotle's dressy ghost is satisfied.


Being HIV-positive does not, obviously, "define" me. No single attribute or fact about a person can ever be definitive. It is nevertheless, just as obviously, a part of who I am -- part of the hum of life, as I said earlier. And why be ashamed, or silent, about that?      


Show Comment(s)

Comments on Jay Vithalani's blog entry ""Why did you come out?" "Because.""

I have no idea why the final paragraph is in grey rather than black.

I was wrong about Hug a Vegetarian Day: it's the last Friday in September. Next year it will take place on September 23.

Today is Be Bald and Be Free Day.


Yes, I was wondering about the causes of that final paragraph showing up in gray (vanishing off the screen with those gentle final words?). Now that I know that you don't know: what a fantastic essay (who but JV would follow the question "why did you come out?" with a lecture on Aristotelian theory of causation)! An inimitable, lovely read.

I woke up this morning dying to reading Poz and jumped at the chance to have your 2nd and 3rd blog bring me out of my San Francisco fog. I adore reading your dreamy witty prose with my decaf coffee for some reason it brings a small smile and cozy warm fuzzy feeling to my gut. In Portuguese it's called fofo.
Actually, I loved your coming out story, more so,I adore Poz coming out stories. Years, ago before my Iowa marriage I used to collect them from other guys I meet on line/in person for prosperity, kind of like photos. Those loving stories they went in my photo/love letters/JYA Junior Year Abroad closet with other black books full personal history.
Your public notice of being poz is great if you have Facebook. As a nurse, and since I volunteer as a nurse in a SDI/STD clinic and work with men who have sex with men. I'm more interested in your personal story of how you got Poztive.
And now that you have disclosed publicly how do you tell some one your poz personally, before you sleep with them or have sex with him. In many small ways my coaching men who have sex with men I always try to use a story from a good mentor. And yes your story and approach will be of great value to me. Since, I already look up to you as a mentor. Mostly because your writing is so draw one into your story. My interest in your story and others always help me guide the young and restless
to be able to better negociate a better healthy sexy sex life.
One day a while back a very young man approched me on the street and said you might not remember me but your advice probably kept me bacteria and virus free. I want to thank you.
Alas, in retrospect, you know why was there not someone there long ago who could have advised me some thirty years ago when I was fresh on the streets of America? So keep it coming we are all waiting for you words.
Nurse Doug E.

The second coming (positive out of the closet) has all the makings of a trilogy!
Some people want to know how I became positive, some want to know longevity & others close to my heart say very little & in the best of silence-sharing will understand the Knowing can only ever be mine to know.

Trilogy - well that's the power & strength of where I am now with HIV & Life.

I like your story Jay. My 17 years has mostly been in the background hum of my existence; however, sharing with friends & family over the years elevates my private grapples with demons, my internal dialogues, my acceptance & humorous perspective on life as a more foreground reality.

It's no big deal or protagonist's soliloquy. Living, Learning & Loving are better pills of truth than most antiretrovirals. Truth is those little ARVs have become part of the loving & accepting.

I'm blessed with great health, a playful & child-like exuberance towards life & the knowing that me & HIV have a solid connection. HIV is always fighting for space in this often silent relationship; however, I've learned over the years to say less & to give less keeps me going.

Leave a comment



Blog Roll

Subscribe to Blog

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Jay Vithalani published on October 13, 2010 7:24 PM.

First Words was the previous entry in this blog.

Alphabeticalist is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.


The opinions expressed by the bloggers and by people providing comments are theirs alone. They do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Smart + Strong and/or its employees.

Smart + Strong is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information contained in the blogs or within any comments posted to the blogs.

© 2016 Smart + Strong. All Rights Reserved. Terms of use and Your privacy