Subscribe to:
POZ magazine
Join POZ: Facebook MySpace Twitter Pinterest
Tumblr Google+ Flickr MySpace
POZ Personals
Sign In / Join

Prove It


People with HIV, even more so than the general population, are quite likely to use what is ‘complimentary’, ‘alternative’ or ‘holistic’ medicine. Project Inform’s Hotline LINK receives a fair number of calls about the safety and utility of such interventions, and I am asked my opinion rather frequently.

Project Inform takes a skeptical, but fairly hands off approach to what I will call alternative medicine. We make the following points 1) little reliable, reproducible evidence exists to back up most types of alternative medicine, 2) the ‘decision to use’ is most often based on anecdote and word of mouth recommendation 3) most interventions are viewed as safe (most often true) and non-corporate (less often true) and 4) tell you doctor everything you are doing.

Personally, I have a bit harsher take on this question. Full disclosure: Back in the 1990s, when I was sick I went to acupuncture regularly, and took heroic handfuls of various herbs and supplements in a kitchen-sink effort to support my flagging immune system. As I recently wrote about, one of my dearest friends is the clinical director at an HIV focused acupuncture clinic. Most of my friends are more likely to take an herbal tincture or homeopathic sugar pill than a course of antibiotics.

While I won’t be as provocative as Penn and Teller recently were and call the lot of it ‘Bullshit,’ I will say that I am quite skeptical about most of it.

I don’t think of medicine in terms of ‘western’ or ‘eastern’ or ‘allopathic’ or ‘holistic’ or ‘traditional’ or whatever. I only see two categories: proven and unproven. I don’t care a wit if a treatment comes from the bark of a tree or the inside of a beaker- what matters to me is proof.

Aren’t I a bit of a hypocrite? Didn’t I use Chinese herbs and moxabustion when I was dangerously sick, and now am trashing it? Well yes and, well yes.

When I was sick, I was willing to try almost anything. There were programs that helped pay for acupuncture and herbs, so I tried it. Some of it helped- especially the herbs. What really improved my health however wasn’t herbs, wasn’t massage, wasn’t yoga, wasn’t prayer, wasn’t tweaking my chi- it was stavudine, lamivudine and indinavir- nasty, harsh and altogether life saving chemicals.

I think there is something to be said for herbs. To this day many of the drugs we take have their origin in plants of various types. It isn’t hard for me to understand how a plant- a complex of biologically active compounds- could have physiologic effects.

But it is folly to assume that nature is more gentle or healing than chemistry. The analgesic properties of willow bark were long known, but its bitterness and propensity to shred people’s stomachs limited its utility. When chemists were able to isolate, synthesize and manufacture acetylsalicylic acid- aka aspirin- the world became a better place.

As for things like healing touch, acupuncture, chakra balancing and so on and so forth, I just don’t see it. Just because I don’t understand it, doesn’t mean it isn’t true of course- but the burden of proof is on the supporters, not the skeptics.

There are some supportive data on acupuncture for example, and more equivocal to negative data. It isn’t proper to cherry pick supportive data and ignore the rest. When pharmaceutical companies do that we yell and scream (rightly). When scientists do it, they ruin their careers. When politicians do it, we call them Karl Rove.

One of the most egregious examples of this in HIV tainted Project Inform and literally scarred me. Back in the pre-HAART days, I attended a talk on DNCB- a photochemical that its supporters claimed stimulated a part of the immune system. You bought these little brown vials of the chemical and rubbed them on your skin.

Project Inform supported research on DNCB. The initial data looked promising- people in the intervention group seemed to be doing better than the control group. Turns out the scientist doing the research took everyone who was getting sicker during the study (non-responders) and called them the control group. Project Inform discovered what was going on and immediately distanced itself from the whole thing. However, DNCB was still being sold for years after that.

The DNCB left its mark on me- literally and figuratively. I still have a faint scar on my arm where I used to rub the stuff on. It helps remind me that my job is to be skeptical- to look at all HIV medical claims, whether they come from Pfizer or Andrew Weil.

On that episode of Bullshit, they talked about this 9 year old girl (forget her name) who holds the record for being the youngest person ever to have a paper published in a peer reviewed medical journal. She did a simple, elegant experiment to test the concept of healing touch. Proponents of this misnamed practice believe that you can help heal someone by moving your hands above a person’s body and manipulating their energy fields. This brilliant pre-teen skeptic got together a group of healing touchers and had them put their hands through a cardboard shield to see if they could feel- without looking- whether her hand was there or not. Surely if they can sense and manipulate a person’s energy field, they should be able to tell if their body is there or not without looking. Pure chance would give them a 50/50 shot- they got it right around 40% of the time- less than pure chance.

Like I said- there is only proven and unproven.


Show Comment(s)

Comments on Paul Dalton's blog entry "Prove It"

you dont discredit naturopathy totally as some others in the forum like rants against ayurveda WHICH IS UNCALLED FOR if you doubt naturopathy as most aids sufferers have low fever that ruins liver,kidneys and tires the immune system over years try zamun vinegar against this ailment it will free your system of low fever within 2 weeks with no side affects and you can go on for years just 2 tablespoons morn evening with just inflamed intestines as only sideeffect.DONT taKE COLAS MEAT SUGAR AND TEA FROM YOUR DIET SEE HOW EFFECTIVE THEY ARE ON YOUR SYSTEM TRY ICE COMPRESSES ON YOUR HEAD TO RELIEVE DEPRESSION WHICH MOST GAY MEN SUFFER THAT MAKES THEM VULNERABLE TO AIDS NO SIDE EFFECT EXCEPT SOCIAL NUISANCE.REGULAR VIGROUS EXERCISE STRENGTHEN YOURS LIVER AND KIDNEYS LIKE STONE TRY TO SWEAT BY COOKING EVERYDAY FOR 3 HOURS AIDS WILL HAVE HARD TIME BRINGING YOU DOWN.YOU NEED WESTERN MEDICINE AND NATUROPATHY TO FIGHT AGAINST AIDS NOT FORGETTING KPAX VITAMINS

This brings back memories. I think I tried everything under the sun - including some bizarre experimental stuff, the ingredients of which I never learned.

Spirolina for enery, Chinese herbs to cleanse the liver, enhance the kidneys and support the immune system.

My first doc had me on 200 mcgs of selenium a day back in the early 90s, hoping it would boose my immune system and keep my plugging along. Who knows, maybe it did,

I still remember the first thing I was told by this same doctor though: "Pack on those pounds so when the time comes, you will have something to fight with.

Ah, memories.

I still take a few herbal things, like milk thistle, saw palmetto and Co Q 10 - all with my doctor's blessings.

There has been some discussion that these things work. I don't know if they do.

Like you Paul, what worked for me was Lamivudine, Zidovudine and Indinavir Sulfate (aka Epivir, AZT and Crixivan.)

Were they harsh? Oh, you bet. But they did the trick and I took that combo for 11 years.

Its a very good article to see and to solve their problem and they very caring for their health, and also need more information about this.



Drug Intervention Florida

Leave a comment



My Favorite Links

Subscribe to Blog

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Paul Dalton published on September 11, 2008 11:44 AM.

Merits was the previous entry in this blog.

Harrumph is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.



The opinions expressed by the bloggers and by people providing comments are theirs alone. They do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Smart + Strong and/or its employees.

Smart + Strong is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information contained in the blogs or within any comments posted to the blogs.

© 2016 Smart + Strong. All Rights Reserved. Terms of use and Your privacy